Comparisons
Finder is fine at browsing and weak at everything else. Several apps address that, in different directions.
ForkLift (~$30) — dual pane, excellent remote connections, good bulk rename. The most popular choice for people who move files between servers.
Path Finder (~$36) — the maximalist option. Dual pane, drop stack, file comparison, folder sync. Powerful and busy.
Commander One (free tier) — Norton Commander style, two panes, keyboard driven.
Marta (free) — fast, minimal, keyboard-first, popular with developers.
Terminal file managers — ranger, nnn, yazi via Homebrew. Nothing beats them for keyboard speed if you already live in a shell.
They are all browsers. File search inside them is either Finder's search or their own live scan, and both inherit the same problem: finding a file you cannot navigate to is a different job from navigating.
The two tools solve different halves. A file manager answers "let me work with these files"; a search index answers "where is the one I mean". Owning one does not remove the need for the other.
Finder's own less-known features close some of the gap: ⌘T for tabs, View → Show Path Bar, View → Show Status Bar, and column view for keyboard navigation.
Yes, though development has been quieter in recent years. ForkLift is the more actively updated alternative.
Marta for a keyboard-driven GUI, or a terminal manager such as yazi or nnn.
Everywhere keeps track of every file on your Mac — including the folders Spotlight hides and drives you have unplugged. Free for a day, then $19 once.
Download for Mac